When Will Real Estate Prices Stabilize in the New York Metropolitan Area?

By James R. MacCrate, MAI, CRE, ASA 

Many so called real estate experts have been predicting the bottom to the real estate market will occur in late 2009 or early 2010.  No one can predict with any degree of accuracy the future, much less the bottom of the real estate market in any metropolitan area.  It is important for real estate professionals to remember that real estate markets vary by location.  Some markets will do well while others are doing poorly.  For example, the Detroit real estate market was depressed long before the recession was declared official by the federal government and the beginning of the decline in the New York real estate market.  The real estate market in the New York metropolitan area was driven by low interest rates and by the growth of the financial, insurance, and real estate sectors of the economy which began in earnest in first quarter of 2004 as indicated in the following chart:


Employment NYC 2008

Total employment is now falling with the FIRE and construction sectors of economy taking a big hit in employment beginning with the collapse of Lehman Brothers.  Real estate salespeople, brokers, and appraisers must stop listening to the noise from Washington, D.C., politicians, and others who have mislead us in the past.  What we are witnessing, the economists and politicians have witnessed this before during the late 1920’s, the late 1950’s and early 1970’s.  In order to properly value real estate, one must cut out all the outside noise and analyze carefully what the local real estate market data is telling you. 


On a Macro Basis the Indicators are all Negative 

The recent indicators reported by the government suggest that the economy is improving because the rate of unemployment is declining, consumer confidence is improving, the rate of decline in manufacturing is subsiding, etc.  All of the above and other statistics still suggests that economy is not improving and real estate values will not begin to rebound until the economy turns over and employment begins to increase with an increasing payroll income and wealth.  That is not bound to happen for awhile.


In the New York Metropolitan area, the leading indicators for increasing real property values are all declining, including the following:


  • Population is stabilized or falling
  • Number of households has stabilized or is declining
  • Total employment is declining
  • Total payroll/income is declining
  • Consumer confidence is negative
  • Businesses are still contracting including manufacturing, retail and the financial services sectors of the economy. 

The results of the 2010 Census should be interesting nationwide.  Listen to what the leading indicators are telling you about the macro market. 


Now, on a Micro Basis 

Real estate is fixed and immobile. The value of real property is driven by local indicators which impact the demand for real estate in a specific location.  All the macro indicators referred to above are also negative in the New York Metropolitan area.  In order to determine if the real estate market is rebounding versus stabilizing at a much lower level of activity and prices, the following factors should be analyzed carefully in addition to the factors that generate demand: 

  • Sale price trends
  • Increase/decrease in the number of sales
  • Increase/decrease in the number of listings for sale
  • Increase/decrease in the number of days on market
  • Increase/decrease in sales concessions
  • Response to for sale or for lease advertisements
  • Increase/decrease in the number of foreclosures
  • Increase/decrease in the number of loan defaults. 

These trends are extremely important to watch, but the trends will not reverse until consumer confidence is positive and total payroll/income, employment and the number of households is increasing.  It must be remembered that real estate prices remained depressed for several years after the recessions of the 1970’s and 1980’s.  Why should this time be any different, and, in fact, it is already still worse in many markets.

For additional information on price reductions, see More U.S. home sellers cutting prices: survey and LPS Releases Study That Demonstrates Impact of Foreclosure Sales on Home Prices.


This was originally posted by Jonathan J. Miller under Straight from MacCrate.


August 2009


About Jim MacCrate

Real estate appraiser and valuation consultant for more than 30 years specializing in reviewing real estate appraisals, risk management and quality control.
This entry was posted in Real Estate Market Analysis and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to When Will Real Estate Prices Stabilize in the New York Metropolitan Area?

  1. jmaccrate says:

    But, history is not on your side. I do hope that you are correct though.

  2. “Why should this time be any different, and, in fact, it is already still worse in many markets.”

    Very true. Hopefully the silver lining is in that it won’t take as many years.

  3. jmaccrate says:

    Send a note to those in Congress to visit the web site and read and study history.

  4. Jim:

    Again you have made a succinct and what I believe is an accurate assessment of the situation at hand. If we can now only convince the loudmouths in Washington to follow your lead…..

    Bill Buchalter
    Certified Appraisal Service
    Middletown, NY

Comments are closed.